action/sports pre- assingment

1.)runner-ups:
name of photographer:alyssa schukar

general focus:sports/illness/happiness

3 problems:
-all pictures are at same distance
-not enough strong singles
-some pictures take down others

2 things that areliked:
-the haiti picture ( alot of color )
-the baseball picture

my impression:i didnt really like some of the pictures that she took beacause they werent really that good and i agree woth the judges they were at the same angle.

2.)winning portfolio:
what did the judges note as strengths as they were critiquing it?
judges liked the color and composition he took.

what do you see as strengths?do you see weaknesses?
i agree with the judges he strengths were color but as for weaknesses i really didnt catch none.

3.)contest recap video:
the judges were looking for photos with color they did like back and white but mainly they wanted color. also they were looking for porfolios with no repitiion in photos; as in photos that look like they are similiar. also they didnt want any porfolios with blanks.

part 2:

i disagree with the photographers in part 1:category action with the first picture because i liked how the picture had leading lines and i also liked the photo because i havent really seen anything like it.

i agree with the photographers also in part 1:category action with the runners the picture was just all over the place you rally couldnt concentrate on it.